Study · October 14, 2026 · 9 min read
Minervini, Kell and Qullamaggie Rebuilt: What the Original Rules Achieve in a Backtest
FyndStock editorial team · How we work
We rebuilt the buy and sell rules of Mark Minervini, Oliver Kell and Kristjan Kullamägi (Qullamaggie) as close to the original as daily prices allow, and ran each method as a model portfolio from May 2022 to September 2026. None of the three rebuilds beat the simpler rule our screener uses today in both test periods. And none of them beat the S&P 500.
Our screener scores stocks by the criteria of well-known momentum traders. The rules behind it are simplifications. For Qullamaggie, for example, we check 60-day momentum and proximity to the high, but not the tight consolidation he puts so much weight on himself. So the obvious question was: does it get better if we move closer to the original?
We fully expected it to. These traders' methods are publicly described, partly in books, partly in talks and streams. They've made money with them for years; Minervini and Kell even won the US Investing Championship. Implement their rules more precisely and more should come out of it. It didn't.
How we tested
The most important part first, because it's what makes the numbers readable. For each rebuild we wrote down the rules before the first test ran, and changed nothing afterwards. If you calculate first and then adjust the rules, you'll almost always find something in old prices that looks good. That has little to do with the future.
The test ran on 887 US stocks from the S&P 500 and S&P 400. Each method got a model portfolio with $100,000, 1% risk per trade and at most eight positions at once, plus 0.2% costs on every buy and sell. Stops were treated like real orders: if a stock opens with a gap below the stop, the opening price counts.
And we looked at two periods separately: 2022 to 2024, and 2025 to September 2026. A rebuild should only replace today's rule if it's better in both periods. A single good period proves little, least of all 2025 and 2026, when semiconductor and AI stocks were the biggest winners.
Minervini: the full SEPA approach
Mark Minervini describes a multi-step process in his books. The stock has to meet his Trend Template — eight conditions on price and moving averages. Then he waits for a VCP, a base in which the swings get smaller from wave to wave. He buys the breakout from the tightest point on higher volume, with the stop just below. If the trade works, he sells part into strength and moves the stop to break-even.
That's exactly how we built it: all eight Trend Template criteria including relative strength, VCP detection, a breakout above the high of the last ten days on at least 1.4x volume, a stop below the tight zone (2 to 8%), half sold at three times the risk, the rest held until the price falls below the 50-day line.
The result was sobering. In just over four years there were only 181 trades, and the portfolio made +13%. Our current, much rougher Minervini rule makes +75% over the same period. Since 2025 both are slightly negative. Only 31% of the rebuild's trades were winners, and the ten best together made more than four times the total profit. So the other 171 trades cost money on balance.
What's missing, Minervini says himself: fundamentals. He prefers companies whose earnings and sales are growing strongly. We added that in a second step using quarterly data from the SEC. Result: much worse from 2022 to 2024, much better since 2025. Results that contradictory aren't fit for a fixed rule. That's why fundamentals only feed into our AI analysis as information.
Kell: the price cycle
Oliver Kell, 2020 US Investing Champion, describes a cycle that a strong stock goes through again and again. He particularly likes to buy two points in it. The Wedge Pop, when a stock jumps back above its short-term averages on volume after a weak phase. And the EMA Crossback, the pullback to the 20-day line in a running trend. He sells part once the stock is far above the 10-day line, and the rest goes when the price falls below the lines.
This rebuild was the most interesting one. Over the whole period it made +57%, ahead of our current Kell rule (+42%). From 2022 to 2024 it was clearly better, but since 2025 clearly worse, +27% versus +45%. By our own rule that's not enough.
More interesting than the total is where it came from. The Wedge Pop alone lost money (−11%). The EMA Crossback alone made +68%. And without the relative strength filter, which only admits the strongest 20% of all stocks, the whole rebuild slipped to −21%. So in our test Kell's method works mainly when you restrict it to market leaders.
We still don't know whether the Crossback alone is a good rule. That idea only came up after we'd seen the results. Testing it honestly is only possible on new price data — from now on.
Qullamaggie: breakout and episodic pivot
Kristjan Kullamägi trades two situations at his core. The breakout: a stock has risen strongly, calms down for a few days to weeks in a tight range and then breaks out upwards on volume. And the episodic pivot, a jump after a surprise like strong quarterly results. After three to five days he sells part, and lets the rest run until the price falls below the 10-day line.
We rebuilt both, plus his exit: sell half the position on day three if it's in profit, stop on the rest moved to break-even. Since Qullamaggie only trades fast-moving stocks, only names with an average daily range of at least 3.5% qualified.
The rebuild ended at +38%, behind today's rule (+46%) in both periods. Since 2025 it's flat. One detail is still remarkable: the episodic pivot alone won 51% of the time and had the smallest drawdown of all variants at −13%. There were only 178 signals in four years, though — too few for a verdict.
Qullamaggie himself mostly trades smaller names that barely appear in our S&P 500 and S&P 400 universe. He also checks the catalyst behind a jump, which a backtest on price data can't do. We had already tested an expansion to about 2,100 stocks including small caps earlier, and that brought no edge either.
The numbers at a glance
| Portfolio | May 2022 – Sep 2026 | 2022–24 | 2025–26 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Minervini (SEPA) | +13% | +13% | -2% |
| today’s screener rule | +75% | +70% | -2% |
| Kell (price cycle) | +57% | +12% | +27% |
| today’s screener rule | +42% | +3% | +45% |
| Qullamaggie (Breakout + EP) | +38% | +38% | -1% |
| today’s screener rule | +46% | +45% | +10% |
| S&P 500 | +101% | +52% | +32% |
| Bold: rebuild better than today’s rule over the same period. Portfolio: $100,000, 1% risk per trade, at most 8 positions, 0.2% costs per buy and per sell. Each period starts with its own portfolio. | |||
All three rebuilds do beat random, by the way. A portfolio that trades the same number of randomly drawn stocks on the same days with the same rules ends up negative at the median. So the methods do filter something out. It just isn't enough to reliably beat a simpler rule or an index fund.
Why more precise isn't better
We see two reasons for it, and both have to do with what isn't in the books.
The first is selection. A trader like Minervini might see forty stocks on a given day that meet his criteria and buy two of them. Which two, he decides by chart, industry, news and experience. A backtest, on the other hand, buys every hit as long as there's room in the portfolio. The more precisely you rebuild the rules, the rarer the signals get, and the more the result depends on a few lucky hits. You can see this clearly in the SEPA rebuild: 181 trades, carried by ten.
The second reason is the period. Between 2022 and 2026 there was a bear market, a long recovery and then a boom concentrated in a few industries. Methods that rely on individual breakouts thrive in phases like that but suffer in others. Four years is simply short for a method with a few hundred trades.
It doesn't follow that these traders lack skill. It follows that their skill can't be squeezed into a handful of rules. Their published criteria are a good filter, but they don't replace the decision that comes after.
What you can take away
If you trade one of these methods, use the criteria as a shortlist and invest the time saved in the selection. Keep a journal in which you record why you take one candidate and not another. Those reasons are exactly the part no backtest captures, and after a few months you'll see whether your selection beats the filter alone.
And distrust anyone who sells you a strategy with a backtest without saying when the rules were set. For this article we tested three methods that should all have been better. If we had kept tweaking the rules after the first results, there would probably be a success story here now.
Limits of the test
The test uses today's list of index stocks for past years too. Companies that dropped out of the index along the way are missing, which flatters all results somewhat. Entries happen at the close; the traders themselves often buy intraday on the break. A program recognizes shapes like wedges or bases differently from a person with a ruler on the chart. And four years is a short period. We describe the full rules and all limits on the page How FyndStock works, and the results of today's screener rules in our backtest study.
The screener makes the shortlist, you make the decision
FyndStock checks more than 900 US stocks four times a day against the criteria of Minervini, Zanger, Qullamaggie and Kell. Every strategy page says what the rule can and can't do.
Start freeRebuild FAQ
So the strategies of Minervini, Kell and Qullamaggie don’t work?+
That’s not what the test shows. It shows that their publicly described rules, applied mechanically, don’t deliver a stable edge. The traders themselves pick a few out of many hits and take into account things that don’t appear in price data, such as catalysts and industry themes.
Why did you fix the rules in advance?+
Because if you search long enough, you’ll almost always find a rule that looks good in old prices. If you write the rules down before the test and don’t change them afterwards, you measure whether an idea holds up — not how skillfully you traced the past.
Why two separate periods?+
A rule that only works in one market environment is a lucky hit. 2022 to 2024 and 2025 to 2026 were very different phases. What helps in both has a better chance of helping in the future too.
Which strategy does best in your tests?+
With today’s screener rules, the Zanger strategy: it was the only one ahead of the S&P 500 in both periods and above a random purchase per trade. The lead is narrow, though — over the whole period it is slightly behind the index. Details are on the Zanger page.
Keep reading
- Momentum strategies backtested: 49,000 trades after costs
- Mark Minervini: strategy, Trend Template and criteria
- Oliver Kell: price cycles and moving averages
- Qullamaggie: breakouts and episodic pivots
- How to spot a VCP pattern
This article is for educational and informational purposes only and is not investment advice or a recommendation to buy or sell. Trading securities involves substantial risk, including the loss of your entire investment. Backtests and past results are not a reliable indicator of future performance. FyndStock is not affiliated with the traders named.